Ben Starr

The Ultimate Food Geek

Easy Overnight Old-World Dutch Oven Bread

Crusty, old-world loaf

Homemade bread is one of the most delicious and satisfying things you can make in your kitchen.  I’ve built a wood-fired oven in my backyard in pursuit of that supreme flavor and texture you get from high temperature baking, but you can get near-perfect results in your normal oven if you have a cast iron or enameled cast iron Dutch oven.  There’s no need to spring for the pricey name brand Le Creuset.  You can get an off brand enameled Dutch oven for around $50 at big box stores or stores like Ross and Marshalls, or go for the raw cast iron Dutch oven sold pre-seasoned by The Lodge for around $35.  (The normal cast iron requires more care than the enameled version.)  For what it’s worth, my enameled Dutch oven is my FAVORITE pan, I use it ALL the time.  (For information on using conventional loaf pans, see the bottom of this recipe.)

The key to brilliant bread is slow fermentation (which promotes incredible crust, a moist interior crumb, and big yeasty bubbles inside) through gradual gluten development.  Most people think you have to knead flour to develop gluten.  This is the fastest, and least effective way to develop gluten. The best way is through slow, lengthy fermentation…which has the added benefit of developing actual flavor.  Our commercially produced breads, and therefore most home bread-baking recipes, call for WAY too much yeast, rising times that are far too short, and consequently produce breads that have no character and little flavor.

This no-knead overnight rising method is not new.  While Alton Brown revitalized its popularity in recent years, my grandmothers were baking bread with this recipe 60 years ago.  This method was re-introduced to me by Steve Sullivan of Berkeley’s Acme Bread Company, which was a driving force behind the artisan sourdough movement in the Bay Area back in the 70s.  Steve became interested in artisan bread on a college biking trip in France, where he noticed how vastly different their bread was from our commercial, flavorless loafs back in the US.  You can thank Steve for the fact that you can now get slow-fermented artisan bread in almost every grocery store in the nation these days.

The best breads are made with sourdough cultures…a symbiosis of wild yeasts and lactobacillus bacterias (which live naturally on our skin) that is kept alive by diligent feedings.  Neither you nor I have the time for that, unfortunately.  So this recipe is the next best thing.  It uses a proper amount of yeast…around 1/4 teaspoon of it…followed by up to 24 hours of initial rise, whereas a modern bread recipe may call for as many as 5 teaspoons of yeast (2 packages) for a single loaf followed by a 2 hour initial rise.  Which do YOU think will taste better?

This recipe is so easy and produces such a spectacular loaf of bread that my friends don’t believe me when I show them how it’s made.

The day before you want to bake bread, combine:

17 1/2 ounces (3 1/2 cups) bread flour

2 teaspoons kosher salt (or 1 teaspoon table or sea salt, NOT IODIZED!!!  That’s VERY important, iodine will kill yeast, and you are using such a small amount of yeast, your salt CANNOT be iodized)

1/4 teaspoon active dry yeast

Stir these around with your fingers.  This helps “innoculate” some lactobacillus bacteria into the bread naturally from your hands.  Then add:

12 fluid ounces (1 1/2 cups) filtered water (do NOT use tap water, which contains chlorine, which will kill yeast.  Use filtered water from your fridge, or bottled spring water)

Stir around with a wooden spoon (I use the same spoon each time, which itself becomes a storehouse for a yeast culture) until you have something that resembles dough.  Cover with plastic wrap and let it sit on your countertop for 12-24 hours.  The longer, the better.  Unlike modern recipes, you don’t want this bread to rise in a warm area.  Room temperature 65F-75F is best.

Scoop the dough out onto a lightly floured surface.  It will be much wetter and softer than when you stirred it together.  Knead it a few strokes to push out excess air.  Then twist it between your hands to form a round loaf.  Place a kitchen towel inside a bowl about the same size as your Dutch oven, and sprinkle cornmeal or flour onto the towel.  Gently lay the dough onto the towel, sprinkle more cornmeal or flour on top of the dough, and cover with plastic wrap.  Let the dough rise for 2-3 hours until double.  20-30 minutes before baking, place your Dutch oven into your oven and preheat to 450F degrees.

When the oven comes to temperature, carefully remove the Dutch oven and remove the lid.  Flour your right hand.  With your left hand, lift the bowl with the dough inside.  Flip the dough out of the bowl into your right hand, then flip it again into the hot Dutch oven.  After 1 or 2 times, you’ll get the hang of this very easily.

Using a razor blade or VERY sharp knife, score the top of the loaf several times.  Cover the Dutch oven and return to the 450F oven for 30 minutes.  Then remove the lid and bake an additional 15 minutes, for a total of 45 minutes of baking.

Carefully remove the Dutch oven from the oven, dump the loaf out onto a cooling rack, and immediately pierce the loaf in several places with a knife to let steam escape without softening the crust.  Cool before slicing.

Whole-grain loaf with hemp, chia, millet, quinoa, barley, and wheat berries

The great thing about this recipe is that it can be easily modified to make any sort of loaf you want.  Add a handful of chopped olives for Kalamata olive bread.  Substitute half the flour for whole wheat and add wheat berries and grains and seeds for a hearty multi-grain loaf.  Toss in fresh chopped rosemary and garlic.  Your imagination’s the limit!

If you don’t have an enameled Dutch oven…you should buy one.  It’s the pan I use more than any other in my kitchen.  But if you don’t have the $60 lying around, you CAN make this recipe in conventional loaf pans.  The crust will not be as good, but it’ll still be better than almost any loaf you’ve bought in the store.  The ideal pan is a glass or ceramic loaf pan, but a metallic pan will work.  You may need to use 2 loaf pans, depending on the size of your pans.  After the overnight rise, form the loaf and let it rise for 2-3 hours in a greased pan that’s been sprinkled with corn meal.  (Make sure it’s covered loosely with plastic wrap and that the top of the dough is sprayed with olive oil.)  Preheat the oven to 450F.  Remove the plastic wrap and LOOSELY cover the loaf pan with foil, sealing it around the edges of the pan, but giving enough room between the dough and the foil for the loaf to rise.  (Basically you’re making a foil tent to hold in steam for better crust development.)  After 30 minutes in the oven (20 minutes if you’re baking 2 loaves), carefully remove the foil tent.  Steam burns are possible, so be cautious.  Continue baking uncovered 10 more minutes (8 more for 2 loaves) or until the loaves sound hollow when tapped.

Fairly light for a whole grain bread!

88 responses to “Easy Overnight Old-World Dutch Oven Bread”

  1. Marie Avatar
    Marie

    Well, I have to say, to those of us (How many could it be? Two or three?) who live where all the salt is iodized: It can be made with our salt too. I have made sourdough bread and overnight breads with it many times and it works. The result might be better without iodine, but in my experience the yeast manages to grow despite it. But the rest of you lucky people who don’t live at the end of the world, follow Ben’s advice:)

    1. Ben Avatar

      Oh, Marie, you can’t find non-iodized salt? I’m curious…where do you live? Looks like Sweden from your email address. Yes, you can make this bread with iodized salt, but I would double the amount of yeast. This recipe calls for such a small amount that the yeast has trouble getting started in the presence of iodine.

  2. Marie Avatar
    Marie

    Oh Swedes love to travel and there is a large amount of immigrants from all over the world in that blessed country up north so they do have a great variety of ingredients oh yes they do 🙂 But I emigrated. So I am in the not very big city of Brcko in Bosnia-Herzegovina and a little village called Rajevo Selo in Croatia. The store that sold peanut butter closed so now there is none left, for a while the town was flooded with Muscovado sugar but since nobody had heard of it and people thought that sugar with strange lumps must be bad quality, no store is selling it anymore and the store that offered Worcestershire sauce closed too. So salt without iodine they see no reason to carry.

    It sounds bad, but they do make up for this lack of diversity on the food shelves of their stores with wonderful produce from their kitchen gardens and green markets and my favourite time of year is pumpkin season! Sweden doesn’t have much of a pumpkin season. Right now it is Ramadan and the Muslims then bake a traditional Bosnian bread called lepinja which is baked all year round but during the fast they sprinkle it with the favourite seeds of their prophet Muhammed, black cumin, and it smells wonderful … (and looks like this: http://www.bhstring.net/tuzlauslikama/tuzlarije/viewnewnews.php?id=31313)

    By the way, I love to read your blog and it is rare nowadays that I find anything to read which is really interesting to me. What you write is somehow so effortless and a pleasure to read and I’m learning something new all the time. 🙂

    1. Ben Avatar

      Wow, Marie, you are TOO generous with your compliments! Thank you so much. The black cumin bread sounds delicious. I’ve traveled in the Middle East during Islamic holidays and really enjoyed the delicious treats associated with them. (For that matter, I love ALL foods in all the countries I’ve been to that are “holiday specials.” Particularly the foods in Thailand leading up to the Songkran festival.

      Deep Eastern Europe has always called me like a siren! One day I’ll spend an entire summer and autumn there.

  3. Irmak Avatar
    Irmak

    Hi! This is an amazing recipe and it turned out great even in a loaf pan, but I had a question. I’m from Turkey and we have this amazing rustic bread that has patatoes in the dough, and the crumb is really similar to this so I wanted to incorporate patatoes in this recipe. How do I think I should go about it? Do you think the overnight rising will still be okay?
    And also, I have a turbo oven, what should I do for a better crust? Should I bake it without the turbo setting? Should I leave the foil on longer?
    Thank you so much!

    1. Ben Avatar

      Irmak, I would modify the recipe using 2 cups flour, 1 cup mashed potatoes, 2 1/2 tsp kosher salt, 1/8 tsp yeast, and then just add water, starting at only 1 cup, until you get the same consistency as the normal recipe. It should be a little dry and crumbly, not too wet. You may have to make it a few times to get it just right. Let me know how it goes! Also, your turbo setting will bake this bread faster than the times in my recipe. I would leave the turbo setting off for the first 30 minutes when the loaf is covered with foil, then turn it on for the final 15 minutes to really brown the crust, but watch to make sure the crust does not burn.

  4. Pat Wynne Avatar
    Pat Wynne

    I really want to try this out, but my dutch oven is a 3 qt & looks small for this recipe. What size do you recommend?

    1. Ben Avatar

      Pat, give it a try in your 3 qt. It might work. If it doesn’t, tear off 1/3 of the dough and use it to make rolls or pizza crust, and bake a smaller loaf in your 3 qt!

  5. Dave Avatar
    Dave

    Just pulled a loaf out of the oven about an hour ago. Had to use a loaf pan and all purpose flour and it turned out great. Love the crust it has. I one of those odd people that love the ends of the loaf and it was great. Will definitely be making this again. One question, can this recipe be doubled or will I have to make two batches to get two loaves?

    1. Ben Avatar

      Dave, I’ve never doubled the recipe, but I make multiple loaves all the time. I just make multiple batches in multiple bowls. I would imagine it would double just fine, but don’t double the yeast, just use a little bit more than one recipe’s worth.

  6. Dave Avatar
    Dave

    I’ve been surfing the web and finding several threads and blogs along with recipes about this bread. Many say it’s bland, others love it and can’t get enough. A few say it’s decent but the only it’s good for is toast as the holes are too big for making sandwiches. I will say it is great for toast though it does take long to toast than store bought breads, nothing wrong with that. And for dinner I made an egg BLT sandwich. So much for it not being good sandwich bread.

    1. Ben Avatar

      We serve this bread at FRANK, and universally, people say it’s the best bread they’ve ever eaten. The last word I would use to describe it is “bland.” Maybe some other recipes use less salt? Or don’t ferment for as long? This is easily the most flavorful non-sourdough white bread I’ve ever eaten. I have started using a splash of buttermilk in the liquid measure, which innoculates the dough with lactobacillus bacteria, in addition to yeast. It gives it a more sour flavor, and more tender texture, and makes it YUMMY!

  7. Dave Avatar
    Dave

    Almost forgot, thank you for sharing this recipe. Chances are I never would’ve thought to search for something like this if I hadn’t seen it here. Seeing this has me searching a good slow rise english muffin recipe and I believe I have found it. Will let you know.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Dave, keep me posted on your English Muffin progress. I’d love to try out a slow rise recipe…

  8. Marsha Zoslocki Avatar

    I have had sour dough starter for about a year that I’ve faithfully kept fed and healthy. How would I incorporate the starter into your recipe instead of the active yeast?

    1. Ben Avatar

      Marsha, every sourdough culture is unique. Sometimes you need a long initial fermentation of 2 or 3 days, then a shorter fermentation, then a final rise. Sometimes you can do it all in one day. It entirely depends on your culture. My suggestion would be to follow your tradition recipe to make the dough, then just use the baking method for this recipe…a round loaf baked in a Dutch oven.

  9. Kim Fleming Reynolds Avatar

    Have some rising on my counter right now…four loaves, actually. Going to add two more after a trip to the store. Two white, one cinnamon (with some cardamom, of course!), and a garlic and rosemary. Going to make a multi grain and sundried tomatoes and basil.

  10. Johanna Avatar
    Johanna

    Ben, thank you for sharing this. I’m thinking of subsituting half white spelt and half wholegrain spelt raio. Do you this will work? Also, can I half your recipe to make 1 smaller bread?

    1. Ben Avatar

      Johanna, I’ve never halved the recipe, so I’m not sure how it will work out for you. The size of the vessel you bake the bread in will have an impact, also, so if you are making a smaller loaf, you need to bake it in a smaller pan. Substituting spelt will make a dramatic difference in the texture and flavor…it will not look or taste like regular bread because of the lack of gluten. But give it a try and let us know what happens! It may be that you have to add some xanthan gum to help hold in the carbon dioxide as the loaf ferments so that it rises.

  11. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    uh-oh … forgot to slash the bread. it’s almost done, but taking longer than it should. But so is the one I put in a loaf pan, and did slash the loaf. Wish me luck!

    1. Ben Avatar

      Slashing is primarily a textural thing…it lets the crumb open up. It’s not necessary, technically, for the Dutch bread because the moisture content in there is higher and it takes longer for the crust to set. How did it turn out?

  12. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    I didn’t get to try the round loaf, but it got good reviews. 🙂 I have had lots of the regular loaf pan bread, and it’s fabulous. My partner wanted rosemary bread for her office. (Which is why I didn’t get to taste the big loaf.) I didn’t have any fresh rosemary, but had some dried. I put about a tablespoon dried rosemary in olive oil for several hours, and mixed it into the bread dough when mixing all the ingredients together. I also doubled the recipe, and used about 1/3 whole wheat flour and 2/3 all purpose. All good — no problem with doubling. I love the way this comes out in my glass loaf pan. I can oil the sides and bottom of the bread, and they come out crunchy-tasty not quite oily, which I really like. And the inside is light and very moist. Yum. Thsnks for the recipe and the site — I need to check out some of your other recipes.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Great info, Jennifer, thanks for sharing! I’ve done MANY modifications with this recipe, it’s very flexible.

  13. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    Bummer — I just took bread out, but it wouldn’t come out of the pot. I left it a while (after destroying some of the edgest trying to get it out), and then was able to get it out. But the bottom crust is all moist. I’m guessing it’ll be the same for toast, just not crunchy for eating as bread. Next time, I’ll specifically flour the bottom more, or oil it. Oh, I know what I did wrong — I let it rise in the le creuset. I did this before and it worked fine. Next time, oil. But I’m interested in any other thoughts you might have. Thanks! About how much olives would you put in for kalamata olive bread, and would you omit the salt in the recipe?

    1. Ben Avatar

      Jennifer, it’s not appropriate to let the bread rise in the Dutch oven. You lose ALL the benefit of baking in the Dutch oven if the oven isn’t screaming hot the instant the dough is placed into it. When you place a cold Dutch oven full of bread dough into the oven, the bread doesn’t even start baking for about 20 minutes until the Dutch oven is preheated. So don’t ever do that…let the dough rise in a bowl lined with a dish cloth, and preheat the Dutch oven in the oven for 20-30 minutes before flipping the dough into it. That’s the ONLY way to bake this bread. Then you’ll get a delicious, crunchy crust, and there will be no sticking. You don’t need any oil or flour in the Dutch oven at all. Flour will burn, the oil will mess with the texture. When I make kalamata olive bread, I use about 2 cups of sliced olives and I only put 1 teaspoon of kosher salt in the recipe. (I also like to add a couple teaspoons of garlic powder to the dough.)

  14. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    Thanks, Ben. I think you’re wrong, though, that ALL the benefit is lost when starting with a cool Dutch oven. Maybe most, but not all. I’ve done it twice now, and it worked both times…except for sticking the second time around. The bottom crust doesn’t get as thick or as hard, but the top crust and the inside seem much the same to me. The top crust is fabulous, and the inside of the bread, too. And I’m not sure I like the crust being SO hard and thick as it comes when I use the hot Dutch oven. Oh, and I like messing with the crust’s texture by using oil. I especially like this bread with oil on it, baked in a glass bread pan…but the top isn’t as fabulous that way. That said, I’ve got some dough rising now, which I plan to bake in the hot Dutch oven. I’m having a hard time with the whole flipping the bread dough into the hot Dutch oven, though, so I think I’m going to try using parchment paper. Someone recommended letting the dough rise on parchment paper in a bowl, then lifting the dough up and setting it in the Dutch oven while on the parchment paper. Do you have any thoughts on that?

    1. Ben Avatar

      Jennifer, the parchment trick is just fine if it works for you. What kind of trouble have you been having flipping the bread into your palm and flipping it into the Dutch oven? If you keep your fingers spread out wide, like you’re telling someone the number “5,” you should be just fine unless your dough is REALLY wet. It’s not pretty, and the bread seems to deflate a little, but it puffs right back up in the oven.

      If you actually don’t LIKE the crust, you can bake at a lower temperature, like 400F, you just may need to leave it in for 35 minutes covered and 20 minute uncovered. This will give you a paler, softer crust. As will brushing the crust with melted butter or olive oil.

      This recipe is, however, ALL about the crust…which is the hardest thing for a home cook to replicate without a professional steam-injected oven. Most conventional bread recipes have a soft crust.

  15. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    Hi, Ben. Thanks for your continued thoughts on this. What I really love about the bread is the top crust. And the inside. The bottom crust…was a little much the one time I followed your recipe to a T. But the inside was best that time. So, I think I’ll do it again, and see what I think. My only real problem with the flipping method was the deflation. It didn’t seem to pop right back up again for me. But I think I’ll try it again, and see how it works. Oddly, my oven usually runs a little cool, but for this bread, I have to leave the lid on longer, or it burns on top. Anyway, enough for now. Today’s loaf, which was 2 c. AP flour, 1. c WW flour and 1 c. wheat bran, is awesome for toast and grilled cheese.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Jennifer, if you didn’t get good lift in the oven after flipping in the dough, try lowering your second rise time by an hour. The yeast may have been “spent.” Also, if your oven is running hot, try decreasing the baking temp to 425F or even 400F.

  16. Lyda Pierce Avatar
    Lyda Pierce

    The first time I made this I used 1/2 t yeast and only gave it 12 hours for the first rising. It got bigger and bubbly. The last two times I’ve only used 1/4 t yeast as my friend the chef said that really your directions worked. And I’ve given it 20 or 24 hours to raise. But these last two times, it hasn’t risen much and the dough had hard dry spots around the outside. The first dry one cooked up fine, but made less bread than the original loaf. The last one is about to go in the oven. What am I doing wrong?

    1. Ben Avatar

      Lyda, it sounds like the last two times you baked the bread there wasn’t enough water. That explains the hard dry spots on the outside. Because all flours have different moisture contents when you buy them, depending on their age…and because humidity in the air on the day you bake varies from day to day, sometimes you have to increase or decrease the amount of water in the loaf to end up with the perfect result. ALL the flour in your bowl should be moistened after stirring in the water. If it still has dry patches, add a spoon or two more water and stir again. It’s better to have a dough that is wet and sticky than a dough that’s really dry!

      The less yeast you use, and the longer you give the dough to rise, the better the final bread and crust will be.

  17. Lyda Pierce Avatar
    Lyda Pierce

    PS. Addition to the note above…. The first loaf was the best bread I’ve ever made. It was a big, round, beautiful hard crusted loaf full of airy yummy bread inside. I wondered why for years I and lots of other folks had worked harder at kneading and then bought a bread machine for bread that wasn’t nearly as good nor as beautiful. Thanks for the recipe.

    1. Lyda Pierce Avatar
      Lyda Pierce

      I just put the loaf in the oven– it was really tiny. What’s wrong?

      1. Ben Avatar

        Lyda, how did the loaf come out? Loaves tend to be fairly small when they go into the oven, and double in size before they come out. However, if your loaf came out dense, this means that your yeast was dead when you added it, or you used chlorinated water or iodized salt, which killed the yeast. Or, the loaf didn’t have time to rise. There are many explanations…I’ve had to know exactly how you prepared the bread, what the temperature in your kitchen was, what ingredients you used, and what the final loaf looked like!

  18. ann Avatar
    ann

    Ok. I want to try this bread (thx beena for sending me here). I live in HOT HUMID Ecuador. Any special tips? I try to keep the house a consistent temp but no AC in kitchen means its always warm.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Ann, just let the bread rise in the coolest spot you have. A low, dark cabinet or something like that. You can also let the bread rise on the counter for 4 hours, and then leave it in the fridge for up to 48 hours for the first fermentation. Then shape it into a loaf and let it rise on your counter the final time. If the kitchen is warm and humid, the final rise will be faster than 3 hours, just bake the bread when it has doubled in size and still gives you a little spring back when you touch the dough.

  19. Cat Avatar
    Cat

    Uh…no mention of Jim Lahey anywhere in this article????

    1. Ben Avatar

      Cat, Jim Lahey is lauded for publishing a 21st century book “revealing” this technique to the US, even though many, many homemakers were already using it and had been for generations. Jim didn’t discover it. Steve Sullivan over at Acme Bakery in Berkeley was promoting the no-knead technique 20 years before Lahey. I get a little annoyed when people like to proclaim that Jim discovered or invented this technique, or that his book is responsible for its existence in the US. My grandma was making bread this way before Jim Lahey’s father was born, as were many tens of thousands of other folks at the time Jim’s book was published. Don’t get me wrong! Jim’s work was amazing and helped revitalize home bread baking for many Americans in this century, particular urban dwellers far removed from the farm. But no-knead bread is many thousands of years old, and the credit CERTAINLY doesn’t belong to him, or anyone else, for that matter!

  20. Hector Avatar
    Hector

    First, thanks! You know that something was worth sharing when (almost 2 years later) people are still commenting and asking. Now, my question: What happens if I leave it longer for the second rise? (Let’s say, overnight!) Just thinking about having it for breakfast without waking at 2:00 AM just to knead and leave it again! Any comment/suggestion is welcome. PS: I might try it anyway and share the results. Just trying to take advantage of any prior experience. 😉

    1. Ben Avatar

      Hector, the second fermentation MUST be at its peak when the bread goes into the oven. So, the short answer is NO, the second fermentation can’t go longer than a few hours. But the long answer is ABSOLUTELY, the second fermentation can be stretched as far as 48 hours, or possibly longer, if the loaf is placed immediately into the fridge after forming…and then removed and allowed to warm up and rise for 3-4 hours before being baked. Unfortunately you’re STILL going to have to wake up earlier than normal to tug it from the fridge, because it’s gonna take it longer than normal to proof to double in size after overnighting in the fridge, so ultimately this step won’t help you if your goal is fresh bread for breakfast. If you let the second rise go too long, the dough develops huge holes that it eventually can’t support, and it collapses in on itself when those holes expand with steam in the oven, so you end up with flat, dense bread. You CANNOT let your secondary fermentation go long unless it’s in the fridge.

  21. Elise Avatar
    Elise

    Both of my Dutchies are oval, so I’m not quite sure what to do about letting the dough rise. Any ideas? I could let it rise in a bowl and keep my fingers crossed, or form it into an oval and let it rise on a towel.

    Your blog is starting to look a lot like a to-do list for me. Bread, cheese, yum!

    1. Ben Avatar

      Elise, I’ve baked this bread in an oval Dutch before, it will be fine!

      1. Elise Avatar
        Elise

        It was better than fine! Easiest bread I’ve ever made, and the crust was wonderful. I love to knead, and it was hard not to work it too much when I was forming it.

  22. Liz Westen Avatar
    Liz Westen

    Room temp water I assume??

    1. Ben Avatar

      Liz, I use ice cold water!

  23. Brian K. Avatar
    Brian K.

    This is the 3rd loaf that I have made so far and the first two were the best. I have spent close to $5.00 per loaf in the past buying from our local Martin’s store. With this recipe I won’t be buying bread anymore. It’s hard to believe that such a great taste can come from such a simple process. Thanks Ben, I have been looking for just such a bread.

  24. H. Chmielewski Avatar

    Just made this recipe, and it came out great! It has a lot of depth to the flavor, which is pretty neat when you consider that there are only 4 ingredients and one of them is water. There’s a subtle richness to it that reminds me of the feeling of settling into a hot bath.

  25. Norma Hunt Avatar
    Norma Hunt

    I have been using a very similar recipie for a while,1/4 tsp yeast which I like to start as a sponge, a little flour the yeast sugar and warm water and let sit for a half hour. just seems to work better. i am awful, I made mine for so long I ddont measure my flour but go by look and feel. My kitchen is fairly cool at night so it is pperfect for slowraising for even 12hours until I turn oven on.I do rye flour or others in my dough with whole wheat flour never use white bleached or unbleached. I love it, I tried other peoples breads oven and bread maker and the yeast is so strong that my stomach feels bad after this way I never have problems except tp gain weight.
    that poor person no peanut butter to slather on the hot bread….
    I will share this link as when I am asked I feel weird saying oh I just use enough flour until itis the right consistancy. same with so many recipies …
    I have a dutch oven that I cook with in the wood coals outside, must try bread next time.

    1. Brian Kanouse Avatar
      Brian Kanouse

      Ben, I have tried a couple of loaves using 50% rye flour on one loaf and 75% rye flour on the second. Neither of these rose much more than 15 to 20% of the original volume. They both tasted great, should I expect more rising using these proportions of rye? Both were left to rise 24 hours with the rest of the process was as you directed.

      1. Ben Avatar

        Hi, Brian! I don’t have much experience with anything more than 25% whole grains. I do know that people successfully make up to 90% rye sourdough, but the rise times tend to be incredibly long…up to several days for the first, and up to a day for the final. (And that’s not chilled.) You might experiment with even longer rise times than you have…

  26. Brian Kanouse Avatar
    Brian Kanouse

    A surprisingly good mistake happened while mixing a white flour and rye flour dough. I was distracted while talking with my wife and accidently mixed in one cup of corn meal thinking it was rye. Instead of throwing it out and starting over, I added the rye flour and let it rise for 3 days. I baked it on Easter day and it has great flavor, can’t even pick up the corn meal in the taste. If anybody is interested… 1-1/4 cups white flour, 1-cup of corn meal and 1- cup of rye flour. 2- tbl spoons kosher salt, 1/4 tsp. yeast and 1-1/4 cups water or enough to wet the mixture.
    Thanks again Ben.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Wow, what a happy accident, Brian! Thanks so much for sharing!

  27. […] enough, at the top of the search, I found Ben Starr, who has had a lot of experience in baking Old World breads.  This one was as close to Dad’s […]

  28. B. C. Crawford Avatar

    When you make the multi-grain bread with quinoia, chia seeds, and chopped olives, do you mix those in at the same time you mix your dry ingredients and water, or do you add them later. I was wondering whether anything in the olives or seeds might affect the rise in a negative way. I have been making the plain loaf with the four ingredients for some time with good results. It seems that when I make this with whole wheat flour added, I get a denser and smaller loaf. What are your thoughts on this, Ben?

    1. Ben Avatar

      I’d add them when mixing the dry ingredients. And yes, whole wheat flour will render a much denser loaf, because the shell of the wheat is included in the flour, which has sharp edges and pierces the strands of gluten that hold in the air. It’s an inevitable byproduct of using whole flours.

  29. B. C. Crawford Avatar

    One other question, do the quinoia and chia seeds sprout or become more tender during this rising process? I have used quinoia before in a bread machine, but it was still very hard/gritty in texture.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Great question, BC. I haven’t noticed sprouting with seeds…you’d have to let it ferment for several days to notice anything like that. In my experience, quinoa is still crunchy in baked applications. If you want to include it, I’d simmer it first to soften it if you don’t like that gritty texture. Personally, I love it!

  30. theresa Avatar
    theresa

    I am very excited to try this. I have been trying to make bread for a long time but it never ever turns out. My bread always ends up very dense and inedible. I was wondering, do I grease my dutch oven before putting in the dough? I was also told to always make sure my dutch oven has something in it while it is in the oven, even if it is just water. After reading your recipe, I noticed the dutch oven goes into the oven with the lid. I am just a little apprehensive about doing this since I have never tried this. I am not all that convinced I will get the holding bowl with one hand flipping it to the next etc… is there a video anywhere that I can watch that would show this process? If not, perhaps you could create one;) Hopefully this works out for me! I have just about given up making bread.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Theresa, no oil goes into the Dutch oven before baking, and it DOES go into the oven empty. If you’re using an enameled Dutch oven, over time this WILL stress the enamel coating. (I had to retire an enameled Dutch last year because the enamel started to flake off…however, I had been baking bread in it several times a week for many years, and it was a cheap brand.) No need to worry about your lid unless it has a plastic handle, but I’ve only seen one enameled Dutch with a plastic lid.

      Don’t worry about the process of putting the dough into the hot Dutch. You’ll get it after the first time. Just dump the dough into your outstretch palm, and then dump it into the Dutch. I’ll try to get a video together, but it’s not a tricky process at all.

      Don’t be scared!

    2. Brian Kanouse Avatar
      Brian Kanouse

      I have been using an enamel coated Food Network Dutch oven for about a year so far, baking the best bread (Thanks again Ben). I have not seen any signs of the enamel failing so far. I would estimate that I have baked over 20 loaves it that time. I did notice that when I was shopping for this one, the other brands advertised 400 degree max. If I remember correctly the Food Network is rated at 500 degrees. I purchased it at Bed Bath and Beyond with the cashier’s help of giving me multiple coupons, I paid about $70.00.

      1. Ben Avatar

        That’s great info, Brian, thanks!!

  31. theresa Avatar
    theresa

    thanks for the reply Ben. My dough is now sitting on my counter top. I am crossing my fingers that this time my family will actually be able to eat fresh bread as opposed to just smelling it and then spitting it out ( yeah, that bad)! I will definitely post my results since everyone seems to have success with your recipe.

  32. Theresa Avatar
    Theresa

    The bread turned out awesome! I am so happy to now be able to finally say that I can make bread. Bread machine for sale! I just had a few questions though. Is there any way I could make the crust softer? It had a great crust but I prefer a thinner/softer one. Also, the bottom of my bread was too cooked. I thought this was due to the oven rack being too low but my 2nd batch also did it. I was tempted to leave the lid on until only the last 10 minutes. Would this make a difference on the crust? I love garlic bread, would it be possible to make some using this recipe? Is there a link that I can go to for a recipe?

    1. Brian Kanouse Avatar
      Brian Kanouse

      Theresa, Did you have corn meal on the bottom of the Dutch oven? If not, having it there will hold the bottom of the loaf off the bottom of the pan so that it won’t get too hot. Funny, that hard crust is my favorite part of the bread. Leaving the lid on might make it a bit softer.

    2. Ben Avatar

      Theresa, you can get a softer crust by slipping the hot loaf into a paper bag and closing it up, or wrapping it in foil. Then the interior will “steam” the crust soft. Keep the loaf wrapped at all times and the crust will always stay moist. However, the point of this particular recipe is to actually GET that crusty outside. It’s really hard to do that with most bread recipes in an ordinary oven. You could also experiment with a longer baking time at a lower temp, like 375, or just leaving the lid on the Dutch oven during the entire baking process.

      It sounds like your oven may be baking hot. So to avoid the burnt bottom, reduce the temp by 25 degrees next time to see if that helps. Cornmeal in the bottom will not prevent the bread from scorching if the temp is too high.

      Regarding garlic…you bet. I’ve done it many times. Chop or slice the garlic however you like, however much you like, or just leave the cloves whole. Add them in when you are stirring all the ingredients together. Sliced or chopped will permeate the loaf as it ferments out at room temp, so go easy on it the first time…no more than about 2 Tablespoons of sliced or chopped…until you get to a flavor you like. Personally, I LOVE it intensely garlicky, so I’ll use a half cup of it.

  33. Theresa Avatar
    Theresa

    I forgot to put the corn meal on the bottom. I did on the top of the loaf but not in my pan. As for the crust, I thought there was great taste to it I am just picky. I went years without eating any ( would eat sandwiches or toast only if the crust was removed) and this was the first time in 30 years I actually ate some. I would eat the whole thing if it was a little softer. But overall, still very pleased with the bread.

  34. Beth Avatar
    Beth

    Can you use this recipe as a base to make a chocolate-cherry bread? Would more water or yeast be needed if adding cocoa powder and sugar? And, at what point would you add the dried cherries? Thanks.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Hi, Beth! You shouldn’t need to modify the recipe very much for chocolate cherry bread. I’d substitute 1 ounce of the flour for cocoa the first time…adjust as necessary. Add the dried cherries in the beginning mixing stage. Let us know how it turns out!

  35. Brian Avatar
    Brian

    Ben, is there a way to keep the crust hard and crunchy? Each time I make this bread the crust softens after the first day. Thanks again for the recipe.

    1. Ben Avatar

      Brian, toss the loaf back into a 350F oven for 10 minutes to crisp up the crust again. This bread is too moist for it to retain a crisp crust on its own.

  36. Megan Avatar
    Megan

    Hi ben. I can’t wait to try baking this bread… But I’d like to get a Dutch oven- as recommended. Seems there are a few different sizes- 3, 6 and 7.8 quart. What size is best? Thank you!

    1. Ben Avatar

      Megan, the 6 quart is the best size.

  37. Elise Avatar

    I’ve been baking this once a week for a few weeks now, sometimes plain, sometimes whole wheat. I think this week I might try adding some honey to a whole wheat loaf, and maybe a second white loaf with a bit of buttermilk. Will the honey make it rise too much? How much should I add? I want the flavor, but the texture of the regular bread is just the way I want it. Oh, and I bought a round Dutchy just for this, since I’m doing it all the time.

    I had the sticking problem some people have mentioned, and I solved it by flouring the loaf after it’s formed, as well as the towel it rises in. My dough was a bit too sticky.

  38. Aimee Chester Avatar
    Aimee Chester

    Hi Ben, I am making my own starter this week for the first time and want to try your recipe with it. How much starter would work? Also, is this slow fermentation process overnight able to produce the bread which is kinder to those who might be gluten sensitive? Thank you much,

    1. Ben Avatar

      Aimee, I use 4.5 ounces of starter, 1 pound 4.5 ounces flour, 3/4 ounce kosher salt, and 12 ounces filtered water.

      I’m honestly not sure about the effect of fermentation time on gluten content. I do know that gluten sensitivity is, for the majority of folks who have it, somewhat psychosomatic, as Dr. Peter Gibson (who actually STARTED the gluten free trend) discovered through recent research. If people are legitimately reacting to gluten but do not test positive in a celiac blood test, the culprit is generally indigestible sugars…NOT gluten. In this case, a longer hydration period will help break down long-chain sugars. Knead the water and flour together and let them sit for 24 hours. Then knead in the starter and the salt and proceed as normal.

  39. Doug Schilling Avatar
    Doug Schilling

    First tried this recipe last year for my wife who is gluten sensitive and seeing it was of very minimal ingredients and processing. She loved it and every time I make it she never experiences any of her sensitivity symptoms. She also makes me use the two cast iron bread pans I bought for my cast iron collection and they work great. Thanks for the recipe Ben.

  40. Sharon Wisely Avatar
    Sharon Wisely

    Ben, what is the best way to store the bread? Thanks for sharing!

    1. Ben Avatar

      Sharon, the best way to store bread is NOT to store it. Eat it! All bread will stale pretty quickly. If you’re wanting it to remain soft, put it in a large ziploc or wrap tightly with plastic wrap. This will render the crust soft, though. For long-term storage, ziploc and freeze. Whatever you do, NEVER store bread in the refrigerator. It dramatically speeds up the staling process!

  41. Lori Smith Avatar
    Lori Smith

    can you add cheese or other seasonings(garlic) to this, and when would you suggest adding them to the recipe??

    1. Ben Avatar

      You can add anything to it, and I usually add them at the very beginning.

  42. William Powell Avatar
    William Powell

    I use iodized salt all the time in my bread; it is lovely bread. Perhaps you should try some regular salt and see if it rises.

    1. Ben Avatar

      William, iodized salt SMELLS like chemicals. If it’s your standard salt, you’re just accustomed to that smell. You get enough iodine from your modern diet and don’t need to use iodized salt. Go off it for a few months, then bring a pot of water to a boil and throw in a handful of iodized salt and decide if you want to cook pasta in it!!

  43. John L Bombardo Avatar

    I tried your bread recipe for the first time,and it came out just like the pix on your website. Can’t tell you how pleased I was, and tastes wonderful, and toasted, is to kill for, thank you for a wonderful recipe and experience.

  44. Tran Le Thau Tran Avatar
    Tran Le Thau Tran

    Dough stuck to the floured towel and pulled apart while putting into the dutch oven. Stuck in the oven anyways.

  45. Fire Within Avatar
    Fire Within

    I had been making half preferment and half fresh made dough I was happy to find this recipe.. I added a cup of ground sunflower seeds and a tablespoon of ground rosemary, part whole wheat flour, a tablespoon of malt barley, a tablespoon of gluten and a tablespoon of potato flour. My tip is to line bowl in the second rise with parchment and lift it into the dutch oven.

  46. Grumpy Grandpa Avatar
    Grumpy Grandpa

    As a baker of bread for many years I agree with much of what you say. I make a range of breads: seeded, wholemeal, sourdough etc. Apart from the taste and smell of home-made breads which is a delicious addition to any house, I have the advantage of knowing what goes into my bread. The slow fermentation process you advocate adds depth and complexity.

    Where I slightly take issue with you is in the pejorative use of the word ‘chemical’. Anything and everything in the world around us, including the ingredients of bread is ‘chemica’l. When we add salt we add ‘NaCl – Sodium Chloride -a chemical. I do agree with you that there is no need to use iodised salt as we get sufficient in our modern diet but iodine deficiency was a major public health problem that was easily cheaply addressed by purposely adding small amounts of iodine to salt. That iodised salt adds any unpleasant odor or taste to food is a moot point that I will leave to others to decide.

  47. mary Avatar
    mary

    this is truly amazng bread. made it once and fixing to make it again. taste and crust wonderful. will never go back to my old recipe again even tho it was great. cant say thanks enough.

  48. Donna Lusignan Avatar
    Donna Lusignan

    I wanted to make 2 loaves but only had one dutch oven so I used a cast iron skillet with a lid….worked great!

Leave a Reply