Easy Overnight Old-World Dutch Oven Bread

Crusty, old-world loaf

Homemade bread is one of the most delicious and satisfying things you can make in your kitchen.  I’ve built a wood-fired oven in my backyard in pursuit of that supreme flavor and texture you get from high temperature baking, but you can get near-perfect results in your normal oven if you have a cast iron or enameled cast iron Dutch oven.  There’s no need to spring for the pricey name brand Le Creuset.  You can get an off brand enameled Dutch oven for around $50 at big box stores or stores like Ross and Marshalls, or go for the raw cast iron Dutch oven sold pre-seasoned by The Lodge for around $35.  (The normal cast iron requires more care than the enameled version.)  For what it’s worth, my enameled Dutch oven is my FAVORITE pan, I use it ALL the time.  (For information on using conventional loaf pans, see the bottom of this recipe.)

The key to brilliant bread is slow fermentation (which promotes incredible crust, a moist interior crumb, and big yeasty bubbles inside) through gradual gluten development.  Most people think you have to knead flour to develop gluten.  This is the fastest, and least effective way to develop gluten. The best way is through slow, lengthy fermentation…which has the added benefit of developing actual flavor.  Our commercially produced breads, and therefore most home bread-baking recipes, call for WAY too much yeast, rising times that are far too short, and consequently produce breads that have no character and little flavor.

This no-knead overnight rising method is not new.  While Alton Brown revitalized its popularity in recent years, my grandmothers were baking bread with this recipe 60 years ago.  This method was re-introduced to me by Steve Sullivan of Berkeley’s Acme Bread Company, which was a driving force behind the artisan sourdough movement in the Bay Area back in the 70s.  Steve became interested in artisan bread on a college biking trip in France, where he noticed how vastly different their bread was from our commercial, flavorless loafs back in the US.  You can thank Steve for the fact that you can now get slow-fermented artisan bread in almost every grocery store in the nation these days.

The best breads are made with sourdough cultures…a symbiosis of wild yeasts and lactobacillus bacterias (which live naturally on our skin) that is kept alive by diligent feedings.  Neither you nor I have the time for that, unfortunately.  So this recipe is the next best thing.  It uses a proper amount of yeast…around 1/4 teaspoon of it…followed by up to 24 hours of initial rise, whereas a modern bread recipe may call for as many as 5 teaspoons of yeast (2 packages) for a single loaf followed by a 2 hour initial rise.  Which do YOU think will taste better?

This recipe is so easy and produces such a spectacular loaf of bread that my friends don’t believe me when I show them how it’s made.

The day before you want to bake bread, combine:

17 1/2 ounces (3 1/2 cups) bread flour

2 teaspoons kosher salt (or 1 teaspoon table or sea salt, NOT IODIZED!!!  That’s VERY important, iodine will kill yeast, and you are using such a small amount of yeast, your salt CANNOT be iodized)

1/4 teaspoon active dry yeast

Stir these around with your fingers.  This helps “innoculate” some lactobacillus bacteria into the bread naturally from your hands.  Then add:

12 fluid ounces (1 1/2 cups) filtered water (do NOT use tap water, which contains chlorine, which will kill yeast.  Use filtered water from your fridge, or bottled spring water)

Stir around with a wooden spoon (I use the same spoon each time, which itself becomes a storehouse for a yeast culture) until you have something that resembles dough.  Cover with plastic wrap and let it sit on your countertop for 12-24 hours.  The longer, the better.  Unlike modern recipes, you don’t want this bread to rise in a warm area.  Room temperature 65F-75F is best.

Scoop the dough out onto a lightly floured surface.  It will be much wetter and softer than when you stirred it together.  Knead it a few strokes to push out excess air.  Then twist it between your hands to form a round loaf.  Place a kitchen towel inside a bowl about the same size as your Dutch oven, and sprinkle cornmeal or flour onto the towel.  Gently lay the dough onto the towel, sprinkle more cornmeal or flour on top of the dough, and cover with plastic wrap.  Let the dough rise for 2-3 hours until double.  20-30 minutes before baking, place your Dutch oven into your oven and preheat to 450F degrees.

When the oven comes to temperature, carefully remove the Dutch oven and remove the lid.  Flour your right hand.  With your left hand, lift the bowl with the dough inside.  Flip the dough out of the bowl into your right hand, then flip it again into the hot Dutch oven.  After 1 or 2 times, you’ll get the hang of this very easily.

Using a razor blade or VERY sharp knife, score the top of the loaf several times.  Cover the Dutch oven and return to the 450F oven for 30 minutes.  Then remove the lid and bake an additional 15 minutes, for a total of 45 minutes of baking.

Carefully remove the Dutch oven from the oven, dump the loaf out onto a cooling rack, and immediately pierce the loaf in several places with a knife to let steam escape without softening the crust.  Cool before slicing.

Whole-grain loaf with hemp, chia, millet, quinoa, barley, and wheat berries

The great thing about this recipe is that it can be easily modified to make any sort of loaf you want.  Add a handful of chopped olives for Kalamata olive bread.  Substitute half the flour for whole wheat and add wheat berries and grains and seeds for a hearty multi-grain loaf.  Toss in fresh chopped rosemary and garlic.  Your imagination’s the limit!

If you don’t have an enameled Dutch oven…you should buy one.  It’s the pan I use more than any other in my kitchen.  But if you don’t have the $60 lying around, you CAN make this recipe in conventional loaf pans.  The crust will not be as good, but it’ll still be better than almost any loaf you’ve bought in the store.  The ideal pan is a glass or ceramic loaf pan, but a metallic pan will work.  You may need to use 2 loaf pans, depending on the size of your pans.  After the overnight rise, form the loaf and let it rise for 2-3 hours in a greased pan that’s been sprinkled with corn meal.  (Make sure it’s covered loosely with plastic wrap and that the top of the dough is sprayed with olive oil.)  Preheat the oven to 450F.  Remove the plastic wrap and LOOSELY cover the loaf pan with foil, sealing it around the edges of the pan, but giving enough room between the dough and the foil for the loaf to rise.  (Basically you’re making a foil tent to hold in steam for better crust development.)  After 30 minutes in the oven (20 minutes if you’re baking 2 loaves), carefully remove the foil tent.  Steam burns are possible, so be cautious.  Continue baking uncovered 10 more minutes (8 more for 2 loaves) or until the loaves sound hollow when tapped.

Fairly light for a whole grain bread!

82 Responses to Easy Overnight Old-World Dutch Oven Bread

  1. Ben, is there a way to keep the crust hard and crunchy? Each time I make this bread the crust softens after the first day. Thanks again for the recipe.

    • Brian, toss the loaf back into a 350F oven for 10 minutes to crisp up the crust again. This bread is too moist for it to retain a crisp crust on its own.

  2. Can you use this recipe as a base to make a chocolate-cherry bread? Would more water or yeast be needed if adding cocoa powder and sugar? And, at what point would you add the dried cherries? Thanks.

    • Hi, Beth! You shouldn’t need to modify the recipe very much for chocolate cherry bread. I’d substitute 1 ounce of the flour for cocoa the first time…adjust as necessary. Add the dried cherries in the beginning mixing stage. Let us know how it turns out!

  3. I forgot to put the corn meal on the bottom. I did on the top of the loaf but not in my pan. As for the crust, I thought there was great taste to it I am just picky. I went years without eating any ( would eat sandwiches or toast only if the crust was removed) and this was the first time in 30 years I actually ate some. I would eat the whole thing if it was a little softer. But overall, still very pleased with the bread.

  4. The bread turned out awesome! I am so happy to now be able to finally say that I can make bread. Bread machine for sale! I just had a few questions though. Is there any way I could make the crust softer? It had a great crust but I prefer a thinner/softer one. Also, the bottom of my bread was too cooked. I thought this was due to the oven rack being too low but my 2nd batch also did it. I was tempted to leave the lid on until only the last 10 minutes. Would this make a difference on the crust? I love garlic bread, would it be possible to make some using this recipe? Is there a link that I can go to for a recipe?

    • Theresa, Did you have corn meal on the bottom of the Dutch oven? If not, having it there will hold the bottom of the loaf off the bottom of the pan so that it won’t get too hot. Funny, that hard crust is my favorite part of the bread. Leaving the lid on might make it a bit softer.

    • Theresa, you can get a softer crust by slipping the hot loaf into a paper bag and closing it up, or wrapping it in foil. Then the interior will “steam” the crust soft. Keep the loaf wrapped at all times and the crust will always stay moist. However, the point of this particular recipe is to actually GET that crusty outside. It’s really hard to do that with most bread recipes in an ordinary oven. You could also experiment with a longer baking time at a lower temp, like 375, or just leaving the lid on the Dutch oven during the entire baking process.

      It sounds like your oven may be baking hot. So to avoid the burnt bottom, reduce the temp by 25 degrees next time to see if that helps. Cornmeal in the bottom will not prevent the bread from scorching if the temp is too high.

      Regarding garlic…you bet. I’ve done it many times. Chop or slice the garlic however you like, however much you like, or just leave the cloves whole. Add them in when you are stirring all the ingredients together. Sliced or chopped will permeate the loaf as it ferments out at room temp, so go easy on it the first time…no more than about 2 Tablespoons of sliced or chopped…until you get to a flavor you like. Personally, I LOVE it intensely garlicky, so I’ll use a half cup of it.

  5. thanks for the reply Ben. My dough is now sitting on my counter top. I am crossing my fingers that this time my family will actually be able to eat fresh bread as opposed to just smelling it and then spitting it out ( yeah, that bad)! I will definitely post my results since everyone seems to have success with your recipe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *