Sourdough Buttermilk Beignets

Cafe du Monde, in the French quarter, which serves up only passably good beignets

Ah, beignets!  France’s answer to a donut, only without a hole, and rarely round.  Single-handedly made famous in the U.S. by Cafe du Monde, steps from the cathedral of St. Louis in the heart of the French Quarter in New Orleans…though certainly not perfected by them.  I actually grumble and groan anytime I take someone to New Orleans and they wanna get beignets at Cafe du Monde.  It’s loud, cramped, dirty, and buried in powdered sugar…and their beignets aren’t really that good, anyway, nor is their cafe au lait.  I’m not sure what the hype is all about, unless it’s simply a bow to tradition.

I’ve been making beignets at home for many years.  They are, in fact, nothing more than an old-fashioned yeast-risen sopaipilla, which means that I’ve been making them since I was a kid, but I was just calling them by their Spanish name.  As I’ve been maintaining my sourdough culture lately, I figured for this Mardis Gras I’d try my hand at some sourdough beignets.  But all the internet had to offer in terms of recipes was a recipe that ALSO included commercial yeast.  I’m sorry, but that’s cheating.  And I’ve never been one to turn away from an idea when I couldn’t find a recipe, so I forged into uncharted waters, and the sourdough beignets that resulted were truly remarkable…tart and rich, with a soft, chewy, tender inside and an impossibly thin layer of very crisp, golden brown crust.  They put Cafe du Monde’s to shame…or so said two friends who love Cafe du Monde so much they held an event at their wedding there!

If you don’t have a sourdough starter yet, chances are you probably know someone who has some to share.  And if not, check out my recipe for The Best Loaf of Bread on Planet Earth to start your own…all it takes is organic rye flour and a little pineapple juice, followed up with bread flour and filtered water.  4 or 5 days later, you’ll have a healthy starter (called a “barm”) that only needs to be fed a couple of times a month, and will make the most spectacular breads, biscuits, pancakes, and beignets you’ve ever dreamed of.

In the bowl of your stand mixer, combine:

1 cup barm or sourdough starter (see below if you want to make these with commercial yeast)
3 cups unbleached flour (bread flour is also okay)
1/4 cup sugar
1 teaspoon kosher salt (or 1/2 teaspoon table salt NOT IODIZED!)
2 Tablespoons melted butter
3/4 cup buttermilk

Knead with the dough hook for about 5 minutes.  The dough should be firm and clear the bottom of the bowl.  If it doesn’t, add a bit more flour.  If it’s too dry and doesn’t come together, add a splash more buttermilk.

(To make beignets without sourdough starter, microwave the buttermilk for about 45 seconds, or until it’s warm to the touch.  If it looks separated, just stir it back together.  Add half of the 1/4 cup of sugar to the buttermilk, along with 1 teaspoon of yeast, or half a packet.  Let it sit for 15 minutes, then proceed with the recipe.  You may have to add a bit more buttermilk to get the dough just right.)

Transfer the dough to a bowl that’s been lightly sprayed or oiled, then cover with plastic wrap and let ferment on your countertop for 4-12 hours.  For really amazing flavor and crust texture, after the initial ferment, place it in your fridge for up to 2 days before frying.

When you get ready to fry, pour about 2″ of canola oil into a heavy pot over medium heat (or preheat your deep fryer) and bring the oil to 325F.  Pinch off a ball of dough about the size of 2 golf balls.  Roll out on a lightly floured surface to about 1/4″ thick.  Then cut that flattened dough into 4 pieces with a knife or pizza roller.  Don’t worry about making them look symmetrical.  This is a rustic dessert.  Drop the dough pieces into the hot oil and fry, 4 at a time, flipping often, until the beignets are golden brown on both sides, and nicely puffed up.  Transfer to a cooling rack set over a baking sheet to drain for a few seconds, then dust with powdered sugar.  Enjoy while still warm, and you’ll think you’ve died and gone to heaven!

Cafe du Monde...eat your heart out!

21 Responses to Sourdough Buttermilk Beignets

  1. Wow! Delicious!! I used a starter that I feed with 1/2 whole wheat flour and 1/2 white flour and substituted 1 cup of fresh ground whole wheat flour and they turned out so well! Of course better than the boxed version but also with a much better nutrtional profile. I did find that they cooked better at 350° oil.

  2. Oh thank you, thank you! I googled a search for a beignet recipe made with sourdough starter and was led to you. I’m always looking for ways to use up my leftover starter. I can’t bear to throw it away. I am going to make these this week!! I have a hankering for fried “something” so this should do it. If you haven’t already, maybe you can invent a recipe for Loukoumades, the Greek version of beignets using starter???? ( :

    • Dana, I hope you enjoy the recipe! It should be super easy to convert any Loukoumades recipe to sourdough. Leave out the commercial yeast, and substitute about 5 ounces sourdough starter. (Back off on the liquid content in the recipe an ounce or two, because the starter has liquid in it. You can always add a splash more milk or water to get the right texture.) The 5 ounces will still need 12-24 hours for the first rise. (If you start with 10 ounces starter, pull back 1 cup of flour in the recipe, and your dough should be ready in 6-8 hours for same-day use.) I’ve found that when I take most bread recipes that call for 4ish cups of flour (or about 1 pound 4 ounces), 4-5 ounces starter substitutes nicely for the commercial yeast, and the recipe doesn’t really have to be modified at all other than that. The only change is that the rising time is significantly longer to develop that flavor.

  3. Ay Frank. Thanks a ton for developing this beignet sourdough masterpiece. I went to NOLA the year after Katrina to help out for a couple years. Love the city. Love the people. Love the food. And yup, the Cafe Du Monde beignets that I remembered from the 80s and didn’t know any better. My 9 year old step daughter Ali looks at me as a doughnut god. She would have these crappy crispy creme on Sunday after Mass and thought they were amazing. What to kids know? Since I just developed my own sourdough starter and also obtained a sourdough starter that originated in the mid 1700s in Vermont from King Arthur Flour company, I immediately went on the search for sourdough beignets and found your masterpiece. Thanks a million!

  4. This sounds amazing. Thanks for spreading the Beignet heaven. I had them in New Orleans about 30 years ago, then again when I lived in NOLA a couple years after Katrina. Cafe DuMonde Beignets weren’t as good to me as 30 years ago. I just started my own Sourdough starter by catching the yeast in my kitchen and am loving it, but as I was in the baking aisle, getting some more whole wheat flour, I see a box of the Cafe Du Monde mix and I says to myself, I can probably find a sourdough masterpiece that will outdo the box crap, and BAM, here I am with my double batch doing a second ferment in the Fridge for tomorrow morning Beignets the old fashioned way. THANKS AGAIN.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *